>>1227540 @ Puru
So E/Ex calls itself an archive. I think that as such it should categorize its content as accurately as possible.
Whether we need that here is another matter.
>>1227540 @ Puru
Why the fuck wouldn't people want a tag for Rimming, surely you don't want to suggest merging it with cunnilingus? subtags are also very relevant for Vore, Pegging could have been handled by anal+strapon but people get very very buthurt about the mere mention of pegging for some reason so fine if they can blacklist it I guess.
The vanilla tag in this context is literally Anal Intercourse, "vanilla" in itself would be a completely fucking useless tag because of how context-dependent it is. https://ehwiki.org/wiki/Talk:Tagging_To-Do
>>1227537 @ Puru
Anal covers regular anal, Pegging, sex toys (tail plugs especially) rimjobs, anal vore, prostate massage/fingering, anal birth, tentacles, fisting, foot insertion and probably a few more that I didn't think of.
Anal Intercourse was added on Ex because it was decided that Anal was so incredibly broad people needed a more specific tag to narrow it down to the run of the mill "penis or strapon in ass" stuff.
Back when I was less experienced I agreed with Shirou, now that I am more educated on the matter, I see the value it provides but haven't gotten a clear indication our community needs it.
>>1227536 @ Marik
^
It shouldn't have been a tag in the first place...but its had years to ingrain itself so even though people aren't actually using it there'd be backlash if it was deleted now.
>>1227533 @ Glovelove
I think you and I have a misunderstanding. The word "we" doesn't stand for some orange name. It means we moderators and our future moderators should approve those tags that we think we should have here on Pururin. And not reject the tag because we (moderators) have no motivation or time to maintain it. Does that make sense?.
We do already have Anal / アナル, why do we need an "Anal Intercourse". That pretty much covers it.
>>1227505 @ Glovelove
I find tsundere usually come across poorly in most works. There is usually too little scope for them to come across well. And just because a character is recalcitrant at the beginning doesn't make it a tsundere.
>>1227525 @ Puru
We're not going to add 200 new tags because some orange name thought we needed it then only uses it on 2 galleries.
If no one likes a tag enough to use it substansialy we don't need it. Ex tags sorta get a free pass on this because they don't rely as heavily on our userbase, but even there I've never considered Anal Intercourse (which Shiou vetoed because he thought it was stupid, but Shirou's takes on anything beyond vanilla are pretty stupid so it shouldn't be a dealbreaker, but it is by far the biggest ex-exclusive tag to port over) to be needed simply because no one even cares enough to ask for it.
>>1227505 @ Glovelove
That's why I am going to change it. That main requirement is no longer a requirement. It doesn't matter if no one has the motivation or time to maintain it. As long as we need the tag, we must have it.
It has never been a requirement, the main requirement has been "does anyone active have time/motivation to maintain this" (which usually boiled down to the same thing, Shirou already had his own pet tags forced through and no one has been contributing to Tsundere since. Ugly Bastard and Happy Sex are the only ones that have gotten sufficient support from non-moderators) and it only applied when doing things we couldn't just import from ex.
When exhentai has the tag the work is still there but the burden it gives is way lighter because ex is making sure its applied on new uploads and if we delay adding it on our end a bit we can copy their homework adding it to older galleries as well instead of doing everything ourselves. (sure we're still tagging it on old galleries ourselves that way but verifying tags from ex takes a lot less effort than finding it before they've tagged it)
![Introducing! Gallar's new Pokemon, Ona'nah! [#Sonia] / Introducing! Gallar's new Pokemon, Ona'nah! [#Sonia] [Woomochichi] [Pokemon]](https://i.pururin.me/85dc1445-d93e-4b90-a130-608c6d13b907_5183/cover.jpg)
![Camelia The First / Camelia The First [Cessa] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/5151c07f-5aa6-4b83-9423-7fedc38817fa_787/cover.jpg)
![A Story About Stealing The Tomboy Childhood Friend From Harem Rom-Com Protagonist 2 / A Story About Stealing The Tomboy Childhood Friend From Harem Rom-Com Protagonist 2 [Sambalteracy] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/5f3721ce-bdef-4004-98e5-7f03de5d76a7_5183/cover.jpg)
![Our Gyaru Girlfriend 2 / 俺たちのギャル彼女 2 [Rukia] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/30482a7b-d641-4841-9a51-f75dc0cddf88_5183/cover.jpg)
![Tennyson Rivalry / Tennyson Rivalry [FreddyHalloween] [Ben 10]](https://i.pururin.me/0a727df5-375a-4279-958b-3e1524ea1210_5183/cover.jpg)
![Welcome to the Futanari Experience Brothel~ / ふたなり体験風俗へようこそ～ [Momomo] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/d1680fa7-f445-483d-87e7-77eb8b951579_787/cover.jpg)
![Airen Tenmen ~Pink no Yousei-san ga Anata dake ni Miseru Yoru no Kao~ / 愛恋纏綿〜ピンクの妖精さんがあなただけに見せる夜の顔♪〜 [Kurowa] [Honkai Gakuen]](https://i.pururin.me/bf5c1339-6005-4688-8130-1b20c691f207_12067/cover.jpg)
![A Story About Stealing The Tomboy Childhood Friend From Harem Rom-Com Protagonist / A Story About Stealing The Tomboy Childhood Friend From Harem Rom-Com Protagonist [Sambalteracy] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/ffdfdd2e-9c62-4f51-90cb-f7d67f7f5384_5183/cover.jpg)
![Futanari Ojousama-chan ~Senzoku Maid-san ni Shasei no Otetsudai o Shite Moraimasu!~ / ふたなりお嬢様ちゃん ♥♥専属メイドさんに♥♥ ♥射精のお手伝いをしてもらいます♥ [Momomo] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/fbd04065-c40c-4ff7-b8ca-4039770bafcd_787/cover.jpg)
![Lewd Mother Island / 母淫島 [Matumoto Kei] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/2e5f818d-09e3-4bfd-ba2a-a494b0275cbd_235837/cover.jpg)
![Japan Lord Princess Bitchification Project / 日本ロードプリンセス牝豚化計画 [Kakugari Kyoudai] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/bc755961-8caa-4863-9bf7-6d3149a5e1ff_5183/cover.jpg)
![Futanari Girl's Secret Sweets / フタナリお姉さんのひみつスイーツ [Binto] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/e3cef903-8465-49e3-828d-cba2693e2d22_5183/cover.jpg)
![Sexually Training a Runaway Kansai Girl / 神待ち関西娘キメセク調教 [Akiha At] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/082417f7-56d7-4a3b-b8d6-f305eb36f1c5_5183/cover.jpg)
![The rookie policewoman with big breasts who became prey to delinquents / 不良の餌食になった新人爆乳婦警 [Sevengar] [Original]](https://i.pururin.me/03d071eb-8715-4676-a376-e6f2456004ce_12067/cover.jpg)
So E/Ex calls itself an archive. I think that as such it should categorize its content as accurately as possible.
Whether we need that here is another matter.
Why the fuck wouldn't people want a tag for Rimming, surely you don't want to suggest merging it with cunnilingus? subtags are also very relevant for Vore, Pegging could have been handled by anal+strapon but people get very very buthurt about the mere mention of pegging for some reason so fine if they can blacklist it I guess.
The vanilla tag in this context is literally Anal Intercourse, "vanilla" in itself would be a completely fucking useless tag because of how context-dependent it is. https://ehwiki.org/wiki/Talk:Tagging_To-Do
Okay, that's pretty stupid. Why do people still need to specific a tag like
Pegging, rimjob, anal vore.
I still get why sex toy, fingering, and tentacles are tags.
But a specific tag like "vanilla anal". I mean, why can't we just add "Vanilla" and "Anal" on the gallery?.
Anal covers regular anal, Pegging, sex toys (tail plugs especially) rimjobs, anal vore, prostate massage/fingering, anal birth, tentacles, fisting, foot insertion and probably a few more that I didn't think of.
Anal Intercourse was added on Ex because it was decided that Anal was so incredibly broad people needed a more specific tag to narrow it down to the run of the mill "penis or strapon in ass" stuff.
Back when I was less experienced I agreed with Shirou, now that I am more educated on the matter, I see the value it provides but haven't gotten a clear indication our community needs it.
^
It shouldn't have been a tag in the first place...but its had years to ingrain itself so even though people aren't actually using it there'd be backlash if it was deleted now.
I think you and I have a misunderstanding. The word "we" doesn't stand for some orange name. It means we moderators and our future moderators should approve those tags that we think we should have here on Pururin. And not reject the tag because we (moderators) have no motivation or time to maintain it. Does that make sense?.
We do already have Anal / アナル, why do we need an "Anal Intercourse". That pretty much covers it.
I find tsundere usually come across poorly in most works. There is usually too little scope for them to come across well. And just because a character is recalcitrant at the beginning doesn't make it a tsundere.
We're not going to add 200 new tags because some orange name thought we needed it then only uses it on 2 galleries.
If no one likes a tag enough to use it substansialy we don't need it. Ex tags sorta get a free pass on this because they don't rely as heavily on our userbase, but even there I've never considered Anal Intercourse (which Shiou vetoed because he thought it was stupid, but Shirou's takes on anything beyond vanilla are pretty stupid so it shouldn't be a dealbreaker, but it is by far the biggest ex-exclusive tag to port over) to be needed simply because no one even cares enough to ask for it.
That's why I am going to change it. That main requirement is no longer a requirement. It doesn't matter if no one has the motivation or time to maintain it. As long as we need the tag, we must have it.
That's apply today. :)
When exhentai has the tag the work is still there but the burden it gives is way lighter because ex is making sure its applied on new uploads and if we delay adding it on our end a bit we can copy their homework adding it to older galleries as well instead of doing everything ourselves. (sure we're still tagging it on old galleries ourselves that way but verifying tags from ex takes a lot less effort than finding it before they've tagged it)